Back home

Speaking up in meetings

Is Your Performance Management Process Actually Improving Performance?

Nov 2, 2026

Good performance management helps people do their best work. It gives employees clarity about what’s expected, helps managers recognise and develop talent, and creates opportunities to celebrate success, address challenges and improve performance.

Performance management effectiveness comes down to whether those good intentions translate into better conversations, clearer expectations and improved results.

That’s why we’re investing all that time and effort, isn’t it?

Back in my corporate HR days, we put huge amounts of effort into coordinating annual reviews, holding calibration meetings and ensuring employees had objectives for the year ahead.

We had clear deadlines, we trained managers and we had a process for signing off objectives. Moreover we trusted managers to check their quality before approving them.

How did we know they were good objectives?

Well, we knew they’d been agreed. Whether they were meaningful, motivating and specific enough for employees to understand what success looked like was another question.

And agreeing a good objective is only the beginning. Its real value comes from the conversations that follow.

Imagine your CEO asks how this year’s review cycle has gone. You can report excellent completion rates, successful calibration meetings and objectives in place across the organisation.

Then comes the real question.

“And what difference has it made to performance?”

Ah. Now that’s a conversation worth having.

What makes performance management effective?

The CIPD’s guidance on performance management emphasises clear expectations, regular conversations and ongoing employee development.

All sensible stuff. The question is whether it’s actually happening and making a difference. Completion rates tell us how many reviews have been done – they don’t tell us whether employees have clearer expectations, are getting useful feedback or are performing any better.

Instead of creating another dashboard for someone to admire at the quarterly HR meeting, I’d start with four questions.

Four questions to assess performance management effectiveness

1. Clarity: Do employees understand what good performance looks like?

“Demonstrate greater strategic thinking” sounds like a perfectly respectable objective. What would someone need to do for their manager to recognise they’d achieved it?

A more useful objective might be:

“By the end of Q2, develop and present at least two proposals that demonstrate cross-functional consultation, consideration of wider business impacts and clear alignment with organisational priorities.”

Employee feedback or a sample of objectives can help HR see whether expectations are genuinely clear.

2. Follow-through: Are performance conversations resulting in meaningful action?

Regular check-ins create opportunities to recognise progress, address challenges and agree next steps.

Are those actions happening? Are managers providing the support they’ve promised? Are employees following through on their commitments?

The value of a conversation becomes clearer when you look at what happens afterwards.

3. Fairness: Are performance assessments consistent and evidence-based?

Calibration meetings give managers an opportunity to strengthen the quality and consistency of their assessments.

One manager arrives with clear examples of an employee’s contribution and its impact. Another believes someone has performed well, yet struggles to explain why.

Calibration should help managers make fair, evidence-based decisions, rather than simply agree a set of ratings.

4. Impact: Is there evidence that performance is improving?

Depending on the organisation, useful indicators might include quality, productivity, customer outcomes, project delivery or skills development.

In science and technology organisations, that could mean examining project milestones, quality standards or how effectively teams solve problems.

Many factors influence performance, so one improving metric doesn’t prove what caused it. Looking at trends alongside employee feedback and manager behaviour can still provide valuable insight.

These four questions give us a much better picture of whether performance management is delivering value. They’ll also help identify where things could improve.

Some of that might involve the process itself. Much of it comes down to how managers use it, particularly the quality of the conversations they’re having with their people.

The difference managers make

Skilled managers bring performance management to life. They set clear expectations, recognise contributions, give feedback people can act on and address concerns before they become bigger problems.

Whether you have a sophisticated performance management platform or a few sheets of paper, it’s the quality of those conversations that matters.

Some managers do this brilliantly. Others have had little opportunity to practise, are doing it for the first time or have never experienced a difficult performance conversation handled well themselves.

Even seasoned managers can hesitate when they anticipate disagreement or an uncomfortable reaction. It’s human nature to want to preserve relationships, so feedback gets softened, conversations are postponed or concerns remain unaddressed.

Meanwhile, the process carries on quite happily. Objectives are agreed, reviews are completed and boxes are ticked.

You can redesign the process as often as you like. At some point, a manager still has to have the conversation.

And that’s where HR and L&D have an opportunity to make a real difference.

What do we want managers to do differently?

Once you’ve identified where performance management is falling short, the next step is to understand what’s happening in those conversations.

Are managers avoiding difficult messages? Diluting feedback to keep the peace? Agreeing actions without establishing accountability? Or simply doing the best they can with limited experience and few good role models?

Which leads to a question worth asking before investing in development:

What do we want managers to do differently as a result?

These are behaviours we can observe, practise and evaluate.

Give managers opportunities to work with real situations, rehearse what they’ll actually say and receive feedback on how their message lands. Help them recognise when they’re diluting their feedback or avoiding the point, and practise staying clear, constructive and kind when conversations become uncomfortable.

Knowing what a good performance conversation looks like is one thing. Being able to have it when the pressure rises is another.

I’ve explored this further in my article on how to get managers to have difficult performance conversations.

And we can apply the same effectiveness test to manager development: are managers using these skills, are their conversations improving and are employees taking meaningful action as a result?

That’s how we connect investment in manager development to better performance outcomes.

Help your managers turn performance conversations into action

When managers give clear feedback early and consistently, employees know what’s expected, performance concerns can be addressed sooner and HR is less likely to be left picking up the pieces.

My practical, face-to-face half-day Clear Feedback and Performance Conversations workshop gives up to 10 managers the opportunity to practise real conversations, handle challenging reactions and receive individual feedback.

The focus is on helping managers turn what they know into what they do, with skills they can use immediately back at work.

Let’s talk about what would make the greatest difference for your managers.

Sign up to the monthly newsletter here!

Once a month, in the form of an e-letter, I share the best of what I know about leading from the inside out.  That is, recognising how we might have the skills and knowledge to lead and yet, we hit our leadership edge because of our (usually subconscious) internal resistance or limiting beliefs.

The intention behind these letters is to offer gentle perspective or tips on how to uncover your internal blocks so then you can release them and fly.

If you want to receive my monthly newsletter, simply share your name and email address below.  You can unsubscribe any time and we NEVER share your details with anyone.